26 Wholesome Amish Recipes

By Maria W. • Apr 25, 2024

Steeped in culture and tradition, Amish dishes are all things simple and honest when it comes to cooking. Whether you're craving hearty stew or homemade bread, Amish recipes bring warmth and comfort to your home. So put on your apron and prepare to welcome the essence of Amish cooking into your home with these 26 Wholesome Amish Recipes.

recipe image
#1. Amish Country Casserole

After a long, hard day of work, there's nothing better than kicking off your shoes, spending time with the ones you love, and digging into a hearty, satisfying dinner. Amish Country Casserole is the bubbly illustration of what a cozy, relaxing, and delicious weeknight should taste like. Your favorite fluffy pasta rests in a creamy tomato sauce. To ensure you're filled to the brim and ready for a good night's sleep, crumbled seasoned ground beef gets tucked in throughout the sauce. Baked and ready to ease and eat your worries away in less than 45 minutes, Amish Country Casserole is the suppertime solution for a peaceful evening!

See More

recipe image
#2. Layered Amish Bake

There is profound respect for a long heritage of well-made food. Layered Amish Bake comes from that well-known lineage, and we know you will love it! Savory ham and white bread are layered with loads of cheddar cheese and a fluffy egg mixture. To add to the tasty tradition, it's topped with a cornflake coating for a great way to start the morning or even a great brunch. Layered Amish Bake stacks up to be one of the best breakfast casseroles in history! Yum!

See More

recipe image
#3. Authentic Amish Breakfast Bake

The Authentic Amish Breakfast Bake is how you can sweeten your morning in a rustically charming manner! A jammy, tart apple filling bubbles away beneath a crispy, crunchy, buttery oat streusel. Notes of brown sugar and fragrant cinnamon bring a warming sweetness, with raisins and nuts adding to the texture and the fruity fun! Whether you're heading out to the farm or staying in for a cozy day, Authentic Amish Breakfast Bake fuels you with both energy and optimism. It's going to be a great day!

See More

recipe image
#4. Amish Hamburger Steaks

In the mood for some real cozy comfort food? Then you definitely need to make some Amish Hamburger Steaks! These juicy, browned patties are just so tasty, smothered in a creamy, rich, homemade gravy for that ultimate down-home flare. We think these would be tasty with some crispy steak fries on the side or even some roasted veggies and mashed potatoes. No matter what you accompany with these Amish Hamburger Steaks, we know you'll feel right at home!

Click Here

recipe image
#5. Easy Amish Friendship Bread

Here's the secret to making new friends; sharing a few slices of this Easy Amish Friendship Bread! This no-proof-needed bread is basically a dessert with how wonderfully sweet it tastes, with a hint of vanilla baked right into the bread and a crunchy, warming cinnamon-sugar topping. It's a simple, but enticing treat that doesn't even need butter to amaze the taste buds... but butter is a friend to all breads, so maybe just a smear or two. Easy Amish Friendship Bread is welcoming to all, and you'll be feeling the love with each bite.

See More

recipe image
#6. Amish Dumplings

When different cuisines combine, we get really excited. And let us tell you, these Amish Dumplings made us squeal with delight. For starters, the warm and savory tomato soup had us feeling all those cozy nostalgic feelings. But nothing could have prepared us for the tender, smooth dumplings floating around in there. Trust us, it was a combination we questioned at first but now we really can't get enough of it! Amish Dumplings embody exactly what you'd imagine that comfort-meets-nostalgia feeling might taste like... and no feeling can ever top that!

See More

recipe image
#7. Amish Chicken Casserole

Amish Chicken Casserole is the epitome of comfy and cozy. Every bite is creamy and brimming with savory shredded chicken, fresh sweet corn, and the perfect buttery cracker crunch. It will fill you up on its own or you can serve it with a crispy side salad to guarantee you will be extra satisfied. One thing Amish Chicken Casserole can promise you in addition to its great taste... a snuggly nap will be a must after you experience its warmth and depth.

See More

recipe image
#8. Amish Butter Noodles

Amish Butter Noodles set out to prove that you don't need fancy sauces or elaborate cooking techniques to make the most of your noodles. All you need is a little chicken flavoring and rich, creamy butter toasted to a nutty golden-brown and bam! A savory, enriching, heartwarming, and delightfully simple meal ready in less than half an hour! Amish Butter Noodles are rustic and restorative and so, so, so tasty. Nothing compares to their country charm!

See More

recipe image
#9. Amish Potato & Cabbage Casserole

The classic flavors of the Pennsylvania Dutch in a classic casserole! Amish Potato & Cabbage Casserole stacks layers of flavor one on top of another so you never miss out on anything! Tender potatoes and ground meat, covered in a sweet and umami dressing, are nestled in with crisp cabbage and rich, creamy cheese. Just when you thought things couldn't get any more comforting, it's even topped with butter! Amish Potato & Cabbage Casserole may seem humble, but each bite spins a tale of tastes that you won't soon forget!

See More

recipe image
#10. Traditional Amish Casserole

Looking for a hearty casserole that will transport you to the heart of Amish country? This Traditional Amish Casserole will take you there! Made with layers of tender egg noodles, savory ground beef, and a creamy sauce, this tasty bake is the ultimate in warm, comforting goodness. It's packed with bold, satisfying flavors that will keep you coming back for more. Whip up some of this delicious Traditional Amish Casserole today and enjoy a taste of the simple, yet exquisite flavors of Amish cuisine.

See More

recipe image
#11. Sunday Favorite Amish Baked Chicken

Why is this called the Sunday Favorite Amish Baked Chicken? Why isn't it, say, the Saturday New York Chicken? Well, for a bunch of delicious reasons! First, it's done in just over an hour, so you can have it on the table for a relaxing and memorable Sunday dinner with little effort. Second, it is simple, savory, herbaceous, and fragrant, with a seasoning blend perfectly suited for bringing out the succulence of the chicken thighs; it's the kind of rustic cooking the Pennsylvania Dutch would appreciate! Sundays should be for spending time with family, so make a new quick-but-delicious Sunday favorite meal with this Sunday Favorite Amish Baked Chicken.

See More

recipe image
#12. Amish Chicken & Dumplings

The Pennsylvania Dutch know how to make classic comfort food that never goes out of style. Amish Chicken & Dumplings is perhaps comfort food in its purest form; the thick and savory broth, the juicy bites of chicken, the tender vegetables, and of course the dumplings. Is there a food out there more ready to absorb incredible flavors with their tenderness than dumplings? Not that we know of! Amish Chicken & Dumplings will make ordinary chicken noodle soup seem like such small potatoes!

See More

recipe image
#13. Amish Chicken Bake

Don't be a chicken! Give this Amish Chicken Bake a try! There's nothing to be afraid of... we promise. Well, unless you're scared of falling madly in love with this blend of bouncy pasta, perfectly juicy chicken, and garden-fresh yummy veggies; then maybe there should be some concern. But we think that's silly! Don't miss out on the greatness that is this Amish Chicken Bake. It's too good to miss out on!

See More

recipe image
#14. Amish Dinner Bake

The Amish certainly know how to make a hearty homecooked meal! The Amish Dinner Bake packs in nourishment and flavor into a humble skillet; juicy ground beef and soft, sweet cabbage braised in a rich tomato sauce just sounds wonderful. And it tastes wonderful too! This Amish Dinner Bake is a simple, quick, and delicious way to feel full and happy with a great meal!

See More

recipe image
#15. Hearty Amish Bake

Say "cheese!" Oh, no, we're not taking a photo... that's just what we exclaim whenever the Hearty Amish Bake is about to be served on our plate. We love it when the layers on layers of creamy noodles and juicy ground beef are up for grabs. It's just so yum, yum, yum! And like we suggested, there is plenty of cheese melded into each level for the ultimate satisfaction. You could say this Hearty Amish Bake is picture-perfect. And you had better take a picture... because it won't last long!

See More

recipe image
#16. Yummy Amish Breakfast Bake

Yummy Amish Breakfast Bake knows all about the simple life, including just how fulfilling the simple life can be! It's filled with crisp bacon, tender hash browns, and all sorts of cheese, with everything getting blanketed in fluffy eggs. It's all the best of breakfast in one dish, and that's just about the best news you can get in the morning. Let this Yummy Amish Breakfast Bake show you that keeping things simple is the best way to make things scrumptious.

See More

recipe image
#17. Cheesy Amish Breakfast Casserole

Food in the morning is a must. But cheese in the morning, that sure is a pleasure. Cheesy Amish Breakfast Casserole makes sure you're fed with everything you crave just as soon as you rise and shine. Fluffy eggs, crispy bacon, and crunchy hash brown potatoes? Yep, it's got all of that! And you can be purely delighted by all the creamy, melty, gooey cheese blended in. Cheesy Amish Breakfast Casserole has got it all and then some. Get ready to wake up to some cheesy greatness!

See More

recipe image
#18. Homemade Amish White Bread

There isn't a baked good more charming than Homemade Amish White Bread. Wholesome, hearty, and yet beautifully tender and flavorful, Homemade Amish White Bread is actually remarkably easy to put together; it just requires enough patience to let it rise. Once it's ready though, there's nothing quite like smearing a little butter on top or using it for sandwiches. You might just want to bake your bread at home from now on!

See More

recipe image
#19. Homemade Amish Biscuits

Offer us some Homemade Amish Biscuits and we will accept them every single time! Seriously! These fluffy, flaky, warm, and buttery bites are just too good to avoid. Especially when they're smothered with just the right about of melted butter and your favorite sugary jam. They offer so many delicious possibilities that you must experience, too... like using them to soak up your go-to soup or sandwiching your beloved breakfast protein of choice in the middle. So, make your own batch of these Homemade Amish Biscuits and see for yourself!

See More

recipe image
#20. Amish Macaroni Salad

Whether you're heading to a picnic or craving something from simpler times, this Amish Macaroni Salad is the perfect accompaniment. The creamy and sweet dressing twirled around the bouncy macaroni and crispy veggies will really help you appreciate the little things in life. So, sit back, relax, and enjoy a scoop or two of this Amish Macaroni Salad. It's good for the soul and your tastebuds alike!

See More

recipe image
#21. Amish Breakfast Bake

Start your day off the right way with this hearty and delicious Amish Breakfast Bake! This casserole is loaded with all of your breakfast favorites, including fluffy eggs, crispy potatoes, succulent bacon, and a trio of melty cheeses that will make your tastebuds sing. With cheddar cheese for richness, Swiss cheese for nuttiness, and a touch of cottage cheese for creaminess, this breakfast bake is the ultimate in cheesy, comforting goodness. Whether you're feeding a crowd or just looking for a hearty breakfast to enjoy all week long, this Amish Breakfast Bake is sure to satisfy!

See More

recipe image
#22. Amish Sugar Cookies

Amish Sugar Cookies have a long history in America; they hail from an Amish cookbook and might have been around since the colonial period. There really is something classic about them: a melt-in-your-mouth confection with buttery richness in each golden-brown bite. Two different sugars make sure the cookies serve up a truly enchanting sweetness. Amish Sugar Cookies call back to simpler times; they don't need fancy frostings or elaborate flavors. They're good old-fashioned sweetness that feels new again!

See More

recipe image
#23. Amish Breakfast Casserole

Amish Breakfast Casserole actually does hail from Amish country and is hearty enough to keep you fueled for the rest of the day. Three kinds of cheese make this casserole the cheesiest, creamiest, and most satisfying breakfast you could ask for. Add in salty, fatty bacon, fluffy eggs, and crispy hash browns, and Amish Breakfast Casserole becomes a dish that will get you excited for whatever the day has in store for you. Go ahead and slice into this country-style breakfast beauty.

See More

recipe image
#24. Amish Cinnamon Bread

How can you tell if it's a good morning? Is the sun shining? Is the coffee hot and flavored to your liking? Is there a delicate warming aroma of cinnamon wafting through the house? For the latter, a few warm loaves of Amish Cinnamon Bread can provide just that! Every slice is enchanting, swirled with sweetness and spices and soft as only freshly baked bread can be! Good mornings begin with a hot cup of coffee and a slice (or three!) of Amish Cinnamon Bread.

See More

recipe image
#25. Amish Apple Scrapple

Amish Apple Scrapple is like the savory version of french toast. It's loaded with bits of spicy sausage and finely chopped onions. Seasoned with earthy thyme and peppery sage, so you really get all the savory flavors. But don't worry, Amish Apple Scrapple has hints of your favorite apple variety in every slice and tastes best when slathered in maple syrup, so you don't miss out on that sweet sunrise sustenance we all love!

See More

recipe image
#26. Amish Dinner Rolls

With just a little patience, you can transform your leftover mashed potatoes into rich, tender rolls just calling out for a pat of butter or a meaty sauce to soak up! Amish Dinner Rolls are fluffy, perfect pillows — the perfect side dish for a relaxing evening meal or a family potluck. Amish Dinner Rolls have that touch of country cooking that makes them delectable and delightful. Make sure you try them out in sandwiches!

See More

Explore More Favorites