Happy Pie Day! 21 Delicious Pies You MUST Try

By Ashley S. • Jan 07, 2025

National Pie Day is January 23, and you're going to want to get a slice of this! Whether you're craving apple, chocolate, frito, or pot pie — these 21 Pie Recipes are for true fanatics. Whatever your taste buds desire, whether sweet or savory, we have you covered. Check out this round-up for all your pie needs!

recipe image
#1. Dad's Pecan Pie

Some traditions are just too delicious to pass up! One of those is Dad's Pecan Pie. A buttery homemade crust and a decadent filling of sweet and crunchy pecans with just a hint of ancho chile and cayenne pepper for a minuscule kick of heat. This pie really has it all with its distinct balance of sweetness and subtle heat. With rich flavors of brown sugar, vanilla, and even a sprinkle of cocoa powder for color and richness, Dad's Pecan Pie is just the dessert to become a family favorite for years to come.

See More

recipe image
#2. Vermont's Favorite Maple Pie

The Green Mountain State has a favorite treat that really embraces its native flavors... and you can bring those flavors to your home, no matter where you are in the nation. Vermont's Favorite Maple Pie features a buttery pie crust holding up a delightfully rich and luscious maple cream filling! On top is a light and crisp meringue; the perfect contrast to the bold, smoky flavors beneath! Vermont's Favorite Maple Pie is definitely about to become your favorite, too!

See More

recipe image
#3. Cranberry Pie

Don't overlook this tasty seasonal treat! Truthfully, Cranberry Pie takes cranberry-lovin' to a whole new level and we have fallin' head over heels for it! Perched atop a homemade flaky pie crust, these delightfully and uniquely tart cranberries are expertly seasoned with orange zest, orange juice, some ginger, and a touch of vanilla, then baked until bubbly for the best cranberry presentation around. Good things take time and Cranberry Pie is worth every second; truth be told, it will disappear in a heartbeat! Don't you just love a good pie?!

See More

recipe image
#4. Turtle Pie

Turtle Pie makes all the pie similes come true. Is it as sweet as pie? Yep, there's a creamy chocolate layer stacked on top of a peanut-filled caramel layer that all sits on a buttery, chocolate-covered pie crust. That's pretty delightful and tasty! Is it as easy as pie? Oh, you betcha! All you need is a fridge and a little bit of time, and you've got yourself some Turtle Pie! This will help everyone come out of their shells!

See More

recipe image
#5. Grasshopper Pie

We know what you're thinking, and no... there are no actual grasshoppers in this pie. In fact, this Grasshopper Pie is completely vegan: completely dairy-free yet with an incredibly smooth creaminess. Grasshopper Pie is a vintage, nostalgic favorite featuring a vibrant green (hence the name), cool, and minty dessert layered on top of a dark chocolate, crumbly crust. This version of Grasshopper Pie is a way to make your sweet tooth happy while getting around dietary restrictions. You don’t even have to turn the oven on to enjoy this hopping, happening treat!

See More

recipe image
#6. Rich Peanut Butter Pie

Decadence with a smidge of playfulness... that is what you get to experience with every bite of this Rich Peanut Butter Pie. A cocoa-infused crust holds all that creamy, peanut butter filling, with a topping of milk chocolate ganache crowned over a layer of fresh honey-roasted peanuts and flaky sea salt for pure pie perfection! Rich Peanut Butter Pie is an intriguing addition to your "pie chart" that every peanut butter-lover will go nuts for! Rich, decadent, playful, and yet oh-so elegant!

See More

recipe image
#7. Apple Slab Pie

Apple Slab Pie is a slam dunk of a dessert! It gets its unique name for its shape: instead of the typical round pie shape, Apple Slab Pie lays out its buttery, flaky crust and sweet, cinnamon-infused fruit filling as... well, a slab. This makes the pie look distinct, delectable, and definitely worth digging into! It's perfect for sharing and for impressing everyone at the party! Don't forget the ice cream!

See More

recipe image
#8. Broccoli Cheddar Pot Pie

Chicken pot will never be the same. How can it be when Broccoli Cheddar Pot Pie exists? The idea of adding cheddar and broccoli soup to a pot pie and making it the filling? Pure genius. The filling is stuffed with the tender broccoli and that creamy and sharp cheddar flavor you love in a bread bowl... well, now it's in a pie bowl! Oh, and there's chicken! Can't forget that! Broccoli Cheddar Pot Pie will be making everyone wonder what else can be improved with a little soup inspiration.

See More

recipe image
#9. Yum-Yum Pie

Ah, the Yum-Yum Pie: the pie named after the response it gets after being eaten! A crunchy, rich, and crumbly graham cracker crust sandwiches the jammy, tart, and sweet mixture of blueberry and cherry pie filling... it just sounds like "yum" doesn't do it justice! Especially when you reach the creamy layer that helps balance out and highlight the fruit flavors! Grab your spoons and let your oven take a day off, because Yum-Yum Pie is ready to impress!

See More

recipe image
#10. Party Animal Pot Pie

Woo! Let's get this party started! Grab that lampshade and use it as a hat! Get the music playing! We're going to... oh wait, are you hungry? Partying requires a lot of energy, right? We'll need something to keep you going all through the night! That's the magic of Party Animal Pot Pie: it's a giant pot pie that's ready to refuel you and it tastes like a party for your tastebuds! The rich, creamy filling, loaded with savory chicken and mushrooms, the buttery pie crust on top... why doesn't every party have this at the ready? Party Animal Pot Pie might just bring the party to you as people queue up to get a slice!

See More

recipe image
#11. Cheeseburger Pie

The grand tradition of meat pies meets the world’s most popular sandwich! Cheeseburger Pie is filled with juicy ground beef, crispy bacon, and sweet onions and topped with melty cheese. Instead of a bun, the crust of Cheeseburger Pie is rich, buttery pie crust. In less than an hour, you can have a new twist on a classic hamburger dinner on the table, drawing everyone to it with its incredible aroma.

See More

recipe image
#12. Apple Cheddar Pie

Apple Cheddar Pie is a great way to introduce skeptics to the ever-rewarding pairing of fruit and cheese! The sweet jamminess of the apples makes a wonderful contrast to the salty, sharp, creamy flavor of the cheddar. The lovely, warming autumnal spices of traditional apple pie also marry beautifully with the beloved cheese, as does the buttery, flaky homemade pie crust. There's endless rustic charm to this Apple Cheddar Pie, and its balance of sweet and savory will have you constantly coming back for more.

See More

recipe image
#13. Frito Taco Pie

Here's a unique spin on your favorite Tex-Mex flavors. Frito Taco Pie layers in the crunchy delight of corn chips with taco-seasoned juicy beef for a crispy, savory taste experience. With its buttery and light crescent rolls and some tangy sour cream, this pie is a dinnertime delight. Frito Taco Pie is about to make Taco Tuesday a lot more fun, especially when paired with your favorite toppings!

See More

recipe image
#14. Hidden-Treasure Beef Pot Pies

Ready for the most appetizing adventure of a lifetime? Grab all your gear, specifically your most special spoon, and get ready to embark on these Hidden-Treasure Beef Pot Pies. You'll be willing to go over all the rivers and through as many woods it takes to get to these flaky pies filled with a vast assortment of juicy beef and yummy veggies. "X" marks the spot, literally and figuratively, of where all the good things can be found in Hidden-Treasure Beef Pot Pies. And golly, it's 'gooder' than gold!

See More

recipe image
#15. Down-Home Sweet Potato Pie

When the leaves start to turn and there is a crisp feel to the air, some dishes are mandatory to place on the menu. Down-Home Sweet Potato Pie is definitely at the top of the list! Tenderly cooked sweet potatoes are perfectly blended and seasoned with the tastes of fall and placed atop a flaky pie crust. Then, it gets covered with a light cloud of golden meringue that perfectly hits the spot. The best dessert ever, Down-Home Sweet Potato Pie is just like what nana used to make. It will elevate your holiday gatherings, or just an everyday meal, with the tasty hint that fall has arrived. Get that down-home feeling!

See More

recipe image
#16. Chicken Salad Pie

If you are a chick (or dude) that loves chicken salad, we have a switch-up just for you! Chicken Salad Pie takes your favorite bite and adds a little surprise. A crispy pie crust gets topped with all the creamy components of chicken salad that you already trust, along with a cheddar-and-Gruyère-cheese blend melted right on top! Yummy! Who knew there were so many ways chicken salad could be eaten?! Chicken salad chicks (and dudes) know where it's at with this Chicken Salad Pie!

See More

recipe image
#17. Huckleberry Pie

Huckleberries may look like blueberries, but they have a flavor blueberries could only dream of; deep, sweet, tart, and with notes similar to raspberries. Huckleberry Pie shows off this incredible flavor in a truly delightful dessert! The pie crust is rich and buttery, and the filling is creamy and smooth, with a hint of citrus zest for brightness. With its namesake fruit piled on top in all its jammy joy, Huckleberry Pie is a summertime treat that makes everyone berry happy!

See More

recipe image
#18. Garden Pot Pie

Sometimes it's just nice to have some alone time. Searching for some solitude, these calm and composed vegetables made their way into this Garden Pot Pie. And would you believe it, they are actually enjoying a break from their chicken counterpart and loving it?! The mellow mushrooms, fragrant onions, crispy carrots, meaty potatoes, serene celery, creamy cauliflower, and gentle green beans are all fresh, tender, and revitalized in a silky sauce under a flaky, cozy, golden-brown crust. Give chicken a break with this Garden Pot Pie. Allow yourself a moment for reflection, renewal, and anticipation for what this blissful slice of comfort provides. We hope you relish this pie full of vegetable Zen! Can't you just feel the love?

See More

recipe image
#19. Million Dollar Chocolate Pie

Want a dessert fit for royalty? Million Dollar Chocolate Pie is like money in the bank when it comes to rich, decadent taste! An extravagant, creamy chocolate filling sits on a throne of flaky pie crust for a simple yet elegant dividend of exquisite, chocolatey superiority. Crowned with rich whipped cream, this Million Dollar Chocolate Pie takes the cake with its commanding presentation. It's truly priceless!

See More

recipe image
#20. Meatless Spaghetti Pie

You don't necessarily need meatballs to enjoy spaghetti. In fact, you don't even need meat at all! What you do need is this Meatless Spaghetti Pie and all of its cheesy goodness. Sharp parmesan and melty mozzarella come together, with tender noodles and rich tomato sauce, for an unforgettable pasta experience. It's simple, humble, but with a flavor that's anything but boring! It's the Meatless Spaghetti Pie, and it is so flavorful!

See More

recipe image
#21. Cindy Crawford's Strawberry Pie

Actress, model, businesswoman, and baker? Cindy Crawford has quite the resumé! But it'll be that last title that will really impress you when you bake up Cindy Crawford's Strawberry Pie for yourself! A delightfully simple and flaky pie crust sprinkled with sugar serves as the base for a jammy, summery strawberry filling with notes of buttery richness. It's like bringing the gentle warmth of May with you for the rest of the year! Cindy Crawford's Strawberry Pie gets everyone feeling bright and sunny no matter what... and will have everyone requesting seconds!

See More

Explore More Favorites